← All reviews

How we score

How It PLAYS

Smithy, the 4xForge blacksmith, writing in a notebook

Every game, on a screen or on the table, gets scored from 1 to 10 on five pillars, one for each letter of PLAYS: Presentation, Loop, Architecture, Yarn and Staying power. The game’s How It PLAYS score is their straight average. One number never tells the whole story, so you always see all five.

We’re a game studio ourselves, so we know what good design costs. We look for hidden gems and games that deserved more attention than they got, and we tell you straight when something doesn’t work.

The five pillars

Presentation

Video games
Art direction, graphics, UI/UX, sound design and music
Board games
Art, graphic design, iconography, component quality and table presence

Loop

Video games
The core gameplay loop, the thing you do over and over
Board games
The core turn, the decisions you make over and over

Architecture

Video games
World and level design, systems depth, technical performance
Board games
Rules design, systems depth, balance, rulebook clarity, setup and teardown

Yarn

Video games
Narrative, characters, writing and worldbuilding
Board games
Theme, worldbuilding and the stories that happen at the table

Staying Power

Video games
Replayability, post-game content, multiplayer longevity, value for the price
Board games
Replayability, player-count range, expansions, value for the price

A game with no story that doesn’t pretend to have one isn’t marked down on Yarn. We score what’s there, not what’s missing, and say so in the review.

The scale

We use the whole range. A 7 means it’s good. A 10 is rare, and a 3 is possible.

  1. 10Masterpiece
  2. 9Excellent
  3. 8Great
  4. 7Good
  5. 6Decent
  6. 5Mixed
  7. 4Below average
  8. 3Poor
  9. 2Bad
  10. 1Broken

Shelf or shelve?

Every review ends with one of three calls. Nothing in between.

  • BUYWorth full price. Go get it now.
  • WAIT FOR SALEGood game, but wait for a discount.
  • SKIPYour time is better spent elsewhere.

Our rules